Awards Library Board Awards Library       National Mediation Board - Public Law Board Awards Filename Description Results PLB2083-4  Initial Terminal Delay Sustained PLB3304-341.pdf Manning of Helpers Denied PLB5942-43 Removal of level 5 discipline - Failure to properly line & lock main switch Sustained PLB6041-56.pdf Decertified engineer denied right to exercise trainmen's seniority Sustained PLB6171-32.pdf Dogcatching Denied PLB6171-51.pdf Setting Out Cars Out-Of-Block Denied PLB6171-52.pdf Helpers - deducting overtime spent on foreign help Denied PLB6171-53.pdf Engineers required to walk more than 1/4 mile to or from their train Denied PLB6345-38.pdf Dismissal for violation of Attendance Guidelines Denied PLB6390-6.pdf Trainmen's HO Pay Denied PLB6390-18.pdf Yardment - Air tests on ETD Denied PLB6390-14.pdf Trainmen's Code 13 - Air Pay Denied PLB6500-11  HOSL relief in ID service Denied PLB6721-4.pdf Post '85 employee's claim for 6B, 7B, 86, 5B or RW for reduced work week Denied PLB6721-11  Basic days pay for performing air tests in the yard Denied PLB6858-3 Passed an absolute red signal - expunged from Claimant's personal record (brakeman) Denied PLB6858-5 Failure to stop - expunged from Claiman's personal record (engineer) Denied PLB6858-6 Verbal altercation with an Official - Compensation & expunge from Claimant's record (engineer Sustained / Denied PLB6858-9 Failure to hold proper job breifing to identify hazards - resulting in injury to brakeman Denied PLB6858-10 Passed an absolute red signal while fixing broken knuckle - failure to report (engineer) Denied PLB6858-12 Workplace violence Policy 90.4 violation - decision appeal Denied PLB6983  Reinstatement to Service - Case # 2, 3, 5, 7, 9, 10, 11   PLB6983-6  Reinstatement to Service - Misrepresentation of the need for FMLA time Sustained  PLB6983-12  Reinstatement to Service - Violence in the workplace Denied  PLB6983-14 Reinstatement to service - Improper investigation held Sustained PLB6983-15 Reinstatement to service - Failure to report running past a red signal Denied  PLB6983-20  Reinstatement to Service - Failure to blow whistle while passing a MOW crew Sustained National Railroad Adjustment Board - First Division Awards Filename Description Results      FDA25263.pdf Investigation Time Limit Sustained   FDA24856.pdf In Connection With Own Assignment Sustained FDA24603.pdf  Restoration with pay and all time lost in connection with medical disqualification-Zimmerman Denied   FDA24604.pdf  Restoration with pay and all time lost in connection with medical disqualification-Gentry Sustained FDA24833 Pay for all time lost due to wrongful suspension - Failure to leave train in the clear on the siding Sustained       FRA - Locomotive Engineer Review Board Decisions Filename Description Results EQAL2001-01.pdf Certificate Revocation - Intermediate Air Brake Test Sustained EQAL2003-06.pdf Engineer Allowed Unqualified Conductor to Operate Train Denied Check out this link for even more Board Awards  http://kas.cuadra.com/starweb1/nmbks/servlet.starweb1?path=nmbks/nmb.web BNSF Emulator  Web Site BLE&T Member Web Site BNSF Employee Web Site Download Adobe Reader 8 to view files   Discipline overturned due to procedural errors in the conduct of the hearing.   Will Arbitraitor's Ruling Lead to More of This?     Arbitrator Gil Vernon, Chairman of Special Board of Adjustment No. 1141 issues his ruling on the BLE/UTU dispute over the RCO jobs which awards the work to the new "craft" of RCO Wonders. UTU wins and BLE loses? Carriers win and workers and public lose? Did Gil ignore safety, 150 years of established practice and current collective bargaining agreements in order to conclude that it's the computer that is replacing the hogger and that the box is nothing but another communication device like the radio or the fax machine? Does this ruling lend support to Byron Boyd's attempt to force "single representation of the operating emplyees - not for the protection of either organization, but for the betterment and protection of each and every operating employee?" Will this lead to the loss of jobs for 4000 to 5000 UTU members? Only time will tell but you can read the Carrier/BLE/UTU submissions to the panel and the final ruling for yourself at Gil Vernon's RCO Ruling RCO Arbitration Documents (As a personal observation, it seems clear that Gil's ruling that the computer is now doing all the trainhandling is based on either ignorance of the facts of Remote Control Locomotive operation with the current equipment or on a political agenda to support the carriers in the introduction of the technology. Just the other day when this RCOperator was temporarily shut down by a governor overspeed fault and was complaining about having to work with the CRAPTRON junk, the Travelling Hogger advised us to lay down some sand (presumably when conditions require it) in order to prevent wheel spin. Now this sounds like just the sort of thing the computer should be doing but which we are now being asked to worry about along with all our other additional locomotive engineer duties. We would suggest that anyone who buys Gil's argument and ignores the trainhandling aspects of his new job does so at his own risk.) Home Officers Minutes From the Local Chairman Links Timekeeping Agreements Public Law Boards Retirement FRA & Safety Claims Safety Meeting Minuets